Wondering how to spend 72 hours in New York at Christmas? After years of watching holiday classics like Home Alone 2: Lost in New York and Miracle on 34th Street, I finally got to see the magic of New York at Christmastime for myself. This trip wasn’t just special because of the city—it was a festive extension of a family visit to Minnesota, and also marked my mum’s very first time in NYC. For both of us, it was an unforgettable few days.
Although I’d been to New York before, once as a child visiting family in the New England coast, and again in 2018 at the end of a Disney Transatlantic Cruise that docked in Manhattan, this was my first time experiencing the city during the Christmas season. I had high expectations, but what struck me most was just how much the real thing lived up to the magic I’d seen on screen.
Whether you’re planning your own festive trip or just want a sneak peek into a Christmassy NYC escape, here’s how we made the most of our 3-night break: what we loved, what we learned, and what I’d absolutely recommend.
🎥 Does New York at Christmas Live Up to the Hype?
We’ve all grown up imagining a snow-dusted, fairy-lit New York at Christmas—and for good reason. Movies like Elf, Home Alone 2, and Miracle on 34th Street painted a dreamy picture of the holidays in Manhattan. I’ll be honest: I was nervous it wouldn’t live up to those images.
But stepping out onto Fifth Avenue with the Rockefeller tree being installed, holiday music playing from shopfronts, and the crisp winter air wrapping around us, it was exactly what I’d hoped for. Not perfect, not polished, but genuinely magical.
🏨 Where We Stayed: Citadines Connect Fifth Avenue
We based ourselves at Citadines Connect Fifth Avenue, just a short walk from Bryant Park, Times Square, and Grand Central Station. It’s a fantastic location for exploring on foot or hopping on the subway.
The hotel includes a continental breakfast, which wasn’t gluten-free friendly (just fruit, juice, and coffee), but it worked for a quick bite before heading to a proper breakfast spot.
✨ Personal Travel Tip:
Be aware of hidden hotel fees in NYC. Citadines charged $75 in additional taxes for three nights and held $500 on my card as a deposit, something every NYC visitor should factor in. Always check that your deposit card hold is released upon checkout.
🍜 Gluten-Free Dining in New York City
One of the things I love most about travelling in the US is how accessible gluten-free dining has become, especially in major cities. New York is incredibly gluten-free friendly, and I found it easy to find satisfying, delicious options without having to search too hard.
Here are some of my top picks for gluten-free in New York City.
☕ Cook Eatery (Breakfast)
My go-to each morning was Cook Eatery, just 5 minutes from the hotel. It’s a help-yourself setup, and I opted for porridge and fruit, topped with coffee. The food is charged by weight, so watch how full you make your box! All in, breakfast came to under $12 each day.
🥛 Le Botaniste, Bryant Park
A gem for gluten-free eaters. This organic, plant-based eatery has set dishes or build-your-own bowls, all clearly marked. The food was fantastic, and the atmosphere? Peaceful, warm, and perfect for people-watching.
Find them here:- Le Botaniste
🌮 Lolita, 45 West Street
A fantastic modern Mexican just around the corner from our hotel. The cocktails and tacos were divine. We didn’t book, but waited at the bar and got lucky with a table.
Find them here:- Lolita
🥟 Dill & Parsley
Quick, healthy, and gluten-free options galore. I had a custom bowl with drink and dessert for $18. Very filling and full of flavour.
Find them here:- Dill & Parsley
🎭 Festive Shows and Broadway Bargains
New York is famous for entertainment, whether on or off Broadway shows, music concerts, and festivals; there’s always something to see and do in NYC all year round, but Christmas brings even more entertainment.
✨ Radio City Christmas Spectacular
I wasn’t sure if the Rockettes would be for me, but they absolutely were. The dancing, costumes, and holiday cheer made this a highlight. It’s a New York Christmas staple for a reason. Its a big production show, and the perfect show for some festive fun.
You can find out more and check for tickets on their website here
👑 SIX the Musical
If you haven’t seen Six the Musical, you are missing out. We’ve seen it a few times in the UK, but mum hadn’t seen it yet, and we wanted something light and fun, so this was the choice to go with. Think of it as a pop concert with the Ex-Wives of Henry VIII. I did wonder how this show would transfer to the US, and it was just as much fun, with an incredible cast.
We used the Today Tix app to get 50% off tickets. It’s an easy way to score great seats without lining up at Times Square. Just download, mark shows you’re interested in, and watch for deals before you arrive.
🌍 Top 6 Things to Do in New York at Christmas
There’s something for everyone in NYC: culture, shopping, history, art and food. However, if we were to share our top picks for a limited schedule, these would be them.
🎄 Rockefeller Center and Top of the Rock
The tree wasn’t lit yet, but seeing it being installed still felt iconic. We went early in the morning to avoid crowds, and that made all the difference. We’d booked The Beam experience, but high winds shut it down. Go City refunded us instantly.
We also visited Top of the Rock, the classic open-air observatory atop Rockefeller Plaza. It offers some of the most iconic skyline views in New York, especially with the Empire State Building in front of you and Central Park behind you. It’s less immersive than newer observatories like Summit, but it’s a must for first-time visitors, especially around golden hour or sunset for dreamy photos.
👩🌍 DUMBO & Brooklyn Bridge Walking Tour
We used our 3-attraction Go City Pass ($100 instead of $149) and booked a guided tour across the bridge into Brooklyn. A great way to stretch your legs and take in the skyline.
🚀 Summit One Vanderbilt
Summit One Vanderbilt was a self-funded splurge, but well worth the $44 ticket. We chose a morning slot, skipped long queues, and spent nearly two hours exploring the mirrored observatory. It felt surreal, immersive, and unlike any other NYC viewpoint—my favourite new attraction of the trip.
🏙️ The Edge
We also visited The Edge, which is included in the Go City pass. It’s a dramatic, sky-high platform jutting out from Hudson Yards with a glass floor and sloped glass walls. While it doesn’t offer the immersive art experience of Summit, it gives you that thrilling open-air view of the city and Hudson River. If you’re doing both, I recommend Summit for the interactive experience and The Edge for a more classic, heart-pounding skyline view.
Hudson Yards
If you decide to visit the Edge, while you’re in the area, take time to explore Hudson Yards itself, a sleek, modern development featuring shops, restaurants, and the iconic Vessel sculpture. The area has a futuristic vibe, making a nice contrast to the older architecture of Midtown and Downtown.
🚎 Roosevelt Island Cable Car
Roosevelt Island is a slender, two-mile-long island in the East River between Manhattan and Queens. While it’s primarily residential, it’s a peaceful escape from the city bustle and home to several hidden gems, including the Smallpox Hospital ruins, Four Freedoms Park (a tribute to FDR), and scenic riverside paths with postcard-worthy views of Midtown Manhattan.
The real star, though, is getting there. The Roosevelt Island Tramway is one of New York’s most scenic and budget-friendly experiences. For just $2.90 return, it whisks you above the East River, gliding past the Queensboro Bridge and giving you unmatched views of the city skyline.
We timed our visit for sunset, hoping to enjoy a rooftop drink, but the bar was closed for repairs. Still, the journey and the peaceful vibe of the island made it worth the detour. It’s perfect if you’re looking for something a little different and more relaxing than the usual NYC chaos.
🎄 The Reality of Bryant Park Christmas Market
Bryant Park is one of Midtown Manhattan’s most beloved green spaces. During the holiday season, it transforms into The Winter Village, a festive market with dozens of vendor stalls, pop-up food kiosks, and a large public skating rink. It’s free to enter and incredibly central, just a short walk from Times Square and the New York Public Library.
That said, our experience was a bit of a letdown. We visited in the evening, hoping for Christmas vibes, but found crowds, long queues, and few clear gluten-free options. The stalls lacked variety, and it was hard to enjoy with so many people packed in..
✨ Personal Tip:
If you’re going to visit, try first thing in the morning or skip it altogether. There are better ways to get your festive fix.
🍹 LGBT Nightlife Pick: Flaming Saddles
One of my favourite bars in NYC, this Hell’s Kitchen gem has a friendly, lively crowd and bartenders dancing on the bar to country tunes. A great LGBTQ+ spot with personality and strong drinks. Just remember—cash only!
Think Coyote Ugly, but make it gay, and a little bit camp.
🛋 Getting Around NYC: Subway & Transfers
New York is easy to navigate, it’s easier to walk than you may think, maps will make things seem further away than they are, so don’t feel like you have to use taxi, or the Subway, but they are great choices if you need to get someone and have had a day for working. If you’re staying in Midtown, most attractions are within reach.
We used the subway’s tap-on system with our Monzo card (Mastercard exchange rate, no fees). Super simple, and no need to queue for tickets.
You can use our link to get £10 starting balance on your Monzo card:- Here
✈️ Airport Transfers:
It can be a bit intimidating to get to and from the airport, there is a train service direct to the airport and city, and Uber/Taxi can be booked easily too. We can add transfers to your booking for you, or just ask your hotel.
- LaGuardia Arrival: Shared Uber minibus for $30 total.
- JFK Departure: Took the train for $15. Easy, clean, and affordable.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
Is 3 days in New York enough at Christmas?
Absolutely—as long as you plan ahead. With 72 hours, you can cover highlights like the Rockefeller Center, Broadway, and iconic holiday sights.
Are gluten-free options easy to find in NYC?
Yes. NYC is very gluten-free friendly. Look for casual chains or curated spots like Le Botaniste and Dill & Parsley. Always confirm ingredients with staff.
When does Christmas start in New York?
Decorations go up mid-November, with major tree lightings and shop windows ready by Thanksgiving week.
🎁 Final Thoughts: My Honest Take on Christmas in New York
This trip wasn’t just about sightseeing. It was a personal experience that brought together family, nostalgia, and Christmas magic. I went with high hopes and left with real memories that lived up to the movie magic.
If you’re considering a Christmas trip to New York, whether as a main holiday or an add-on like ours, go for it. It’s busy, it’s bold, but it’s unforgettable.
🎁 Ready to Plan Your Own Christmas in New York?
Whether you’re dreaming of your first festive trip or want a tailor-made winter break with gluten-free food stops and Broadway magic, I’d love to help you create your own perfect NYC itinerary.
📲 For more information and to book, please contact us:
Chat now via WhatsApp 👉 https://bit.ly/MagicalTRVLR
📧 hello@magical-traveller.com
🏆 Award-winning Travel Specialist | ✨ 5-star rated | 🛡️ ATOL Protected.
Enquire Now
If you want to book a holiday with Magical Traveller, please send us a message or call any time.
You can enquire anytime using our Contact Us form by clicking here.
You can also contact us via email at hello@magical-traveller.com, or call us on 07307602030
*Note, all prices shown were correct at the time of posting and are subject to change, terms and conditions apply, ask for details and terms